Home / Weblog Consulting Services Publications
Speaking and Media About Dana Contact Dana
Search

www www.danavan.net
Google
Archives:
Categories
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Creative Commons License
Weblog



December 17, 2004
The difference between newsgroups and blogs

Robert discussed the difference between newgroups and weblogs, which, for this audience, is a key distinction to be made, and it's a key distinction for the discussion that I've been having on 'Building Online Brand Communities' through weblogs.

Newsgroups: Weblogs:
The writer decides what you read, in that IF you want to stay up on the happenings of the group, you have little choice but to wade through their stuff The reader decides what they want to read by subscribing, and unsubscribing to feeds from relevant groups, persons or companies.
You can't really 'brand' newsgroup participation or discussion. Blogs, in the marketing space, are meant to be branded.
Newbies can ruin it; you can't get rid of them. Newbies usually ehance it, you tune them out if you don't like them
The value of the group deteriorates as lesser and lesser personalities enter the group and dilute the discussion. All newsgroups start out valuable because they are started by passionate thought leaders, but eventually deteriorate. The blogosphere gets more and more refined as thought leaders enter the space and contribute, and you can choose to subscribe or not to sub. If the content deteriorates, you leave because it's one voice of many in a mutually exclusive space. Contrary, if the content deteriorates on a group, it's many voices in one place, and to still hear the one of the many, you need to stay mired in the crap of the newsgroup.
Signal vs. Noise - Noise overruns eventually, and you can't turn it off or tune it out if you want the content Signal vs. Noise - If noise overruns signal in a blog, you tune it out or unsubscribe.

At the risk of oversimplification, one can say that each blog is equivalent to a single moderated newsgroup. While this makes control better, it makes discovery much worse. Either newcomers don't get noticed or readers have to wade through masses of useless new blogs in search of the good ones.

Post a comment






Remember personal info?







Email This to a Friend
Email this entry to:

Your email address:


Message (optional):