Dana VanDen Heuvel - Wisconsin Internet Marketing Consultant

May 13, 2004

As of 4am PDT this morning, Movable Type sucks

Updates:
- Movable Type has already released another tier of licensing. This one looks a bit more agreeable!
Movable Type Personal License Options:
Authors/Blogs - 3/5 - $69.95
Authors/Blogs - 6/8 - $119.95
Authors/Blogs - 9/10 - $149.95

The "blogosphere" is speaking, and SixApart is certainly listening!

 
   

I was trolling around the MT Beta Blog this morning and found this message:

This morning at 4am PDT, Six Apart is releasing Movable Type 3.0D, the developer edition of 3.0. This marks the first fully-public release of Movable Type 3.0 and along with it, a pricing scheme that makes it easy for people to do business with us, and a new set of licenses that are more permissive than our legacy license.

I personally want you to know that we all really appreciate your help in working the kinks out of this release, and we're also grateful for you patience-myself in particular. In spite of its significant bumps, this was a very valuable beta test, and we went through several hundred bug reports in the past month and a half....


My first reaction was, WTF, you must be kidding, I've just done a bunch of Alpha/Beta crap for fun...and now, WTF? After thinking about it some more, I've progressed in my thinking to WTFF... Les Jenkins was one of the first to start ranting in the MT forums, but is you really want a glimpse at rage, check out the trackbacks to Mena's post on SixApart's site!

On the MT Forums, someone tries to clarify the situation; things are not looking any better:

I think that Six Appart is abusing us by providing MovableType 3.0D with such licenses.

The previous licenses where not at all limiting the number of weblogs nor of authors.

http://www.movabletype.org/download.shtml
http://www.movabletype.org/commercial_download.shtml

With the Movable Type Free you can not have more than 1 author and three weblogs !
If you already passed trough this limit with MT 2.6x you just can't update for free !
More over, if you already have over 20 authors and 15 weblogs you won't be able to update at all, even by paying !
Because of the Commercial License which is limiting to 20 authors and 15 weblogs.

http://secure.sixapart.com/

MovableType is now TypePad proof.

I'm requesting suppression of the limitations to the numbers of authors and weblogs for all the licenses and for the Free version.

Why such griping? Have a look @ the new pricing structure.

So, almost needless to say, I'm pretty pissed off (me writing in on forums):

Wow, what an announcement to be hit with. I've been doing Alpha & Beta testing for quite a while & feel a bit used to get this message today.

I already have 11 weblogs, albeit with one author, I use different "weblogs" as content areas of my personal site. Basically, I'm pretty much screwed and will be stuck on a Beta version forever, because I can't update with these new license requirements.

Needless to say, if this stuff sticks, and it is what it appears, it could go down as a case history on how to lose loyal fans for life in record time!

More on this crap:

Alternatives to MT:


As of Noon CDT, the trackbacks on Mena's post are no longer visible and return only the message [an error occurred while processing this directive]. No shit I say, there certainly was an error in this directive!

Posted by Dana VanDen Heuvel at May 13, 2004 07:40 AM | TrackBack

I've noticed for some time that the 6A gang are quite good at coding, but they aren't too bright in other areas. How do you have a pricing structure that HAS AN UPPER LIMIT to the amount of authors/weblogs??

And you forgot to mention that the fine print says that the licenses are for SINGLE CPU machines. Most hosting facilities are big UNIX boxen, usually with 2 or more CPUs. Double the CPU, double the license fee?? Who knows? I feel sorry for people who are hosted on Sun E series hardware, as they usually have *at least* 4 CPUs

Asshats.

Posted by: CM Harrington at May 13, 2004 09:41 AM

I've heard good things about Wordpress - seems to be the most "MT like" of the open source alternatives.

Personally, I like Blosxom and have successfully installed on a test blog in the past. However, it does require a high geek factor and is not a viable solution for most.

The CPU limit is ridiculous. I'll bet 90% of their user base doesn't even know (nor should they care) how many CPU's are on the host machine.

Posted by: Chris O'Donnell at May 13, 2004 10:09 AM

Seems the Trackbacks on Mena's comments are off the air and also the support site is off the air.

Posted by: Geek at May 13, 2004 11:53 AM

There's no upper limit. Check out the sidebar under "Need something else?"...

Posted by: Jay Allen at May 13, 2004 11:54 AM
Post a comment






Remember personal info?





Email This to a Friend
Email this entry to:

Your email address:


Message (optional):